We're having a boy, but if he were going to be a girl his name was going to be Tierney. My husband hates it cause he thinks it's not a name and it's weird but I love it so in the end he would have caved. Middle names would have been either Olivia, Emma, or Erin (Erin was my husband's pick, and I like it, but I think it makes the whole name sound pretty Irish, and with our very Italian last name that didn't fit too well I thought). If he was still totally again Tierney by the birth then she would have been Julia, but no idea what the middle name would have been.
My 2yo daughter is Madison Alyssa. Madison is I think the 3rd most popular name but we have never met another one IRL. There are none in her entire school (not just a preschool, they go up to 6th grade too) and none in the daycamp she's signed up for. We do know a few Ellas, Annas, and Lillys though.
My friend just had a baby girl and named her Emilia Victoria, which I think won't be too common, but definitely isn't weird either. There's also an Ellen in my daughter's class, which I haven't heard since my 60yo aunt, but I think it's a nice name. Less trendy than Ella, but same nickname possibilities.
Oh, and my niece is a Maya and we all thought that was so odd but there are 3 Mayas in my daughter's school. We all thought it would be reversed-lots of Madisons and no Mayas.