My takeaways from reading a hundred pages of posts today and following wait times on
MDE
1. I haven't seen much to suggest that this had any major positive effect on standby lines at all. The standby lines seemed pretty much what would have been expected this time of year under the old system. Not any worse - but I don't thing the predictions of them being much better look true.
2. I've read very few experiences where it sounded like someone got to do more or stand in line less than they would have under FP+ (other than if they chose to purchase the two ILL options).
3. I've read a lot more experiences where people did less or stood in line more than they would have under FP+
4. You're at a significant disadvantage if (a) you're not up at 7am to make your reservations or (b) you're not at the park close to rope drop. And this is likely to get a lot worse as today would be expected to be comparatively light crowds.
[EDIT: I'll add one positive to be even handed - I think the return times on the LL rides were very reasonable today for most of of rides outside of DHS where they have an overall inventory problem. We'll see if that holds up going forward].
I think it's working just as they intended - but I've seen noting to change my opinion that this hurts a lot of people and helps very few compared to the old system. Almost nothing implemented today was to improve the guest experience - just Disney's bottom line. And to be clear - yes - I understand Disney is a business but usually their changes also sought to improve the guest experience over what had been there. So this isn't a matter of whether you like
Genie+ - it's a matter of whether this improved the experience for a most guests compared to what they could have done under FP+. I don't believe it has based on Day 1.
[EDIT 2: Not there today but a shout out to the cast members who do a great job and never asked for all the abuse that gets heaped on them due to corporate decisions they have no control over. They've always been the backbone of everything at the parks and they're in my thoughts this week!!!!!]