Hey MM, when we booked our our 4 night, it was only pennies more than the three night??? When are you planning on cruising?
Yes, I was not happy to lose our day at sea... One big reason is, how can it be a cruise if you spend the entire time sitting in port. ( I have heard the port at Freeport is a god-awful looking industrial docking area? Now that is a big incentive to want to leave the ship.... ) And, also, believe me, as one who has now planned both ways.... when you have that day at sea, it makes scheduling MUCH easier and much more relaxing! When you loose that, they essentially cram
Castaway Cay, The Kids Show with Mickey, Disney Dreams, the most popular night for Palo, and just about everything else, all together on that last day.
If the time period that you are looking at shows every other cruise as a day at sea, then you know for sure.... If it shows every week as a day at sea, then be aware that the 'every-other-week' pattern could be continued... You would then look at a calander to see what weeks would change to Freeport.
I say, go for at least the 4 night! and go for the day at sea!