We also really like the Beach Club/Boardwalk area with our little one. We found room preferences didn't really matter much, as all had their benefits. It is nice to be on the water for the view, but the "quiet pool" and green areas are much quieter. It depends on your family preferences. I did find noise was not a factor for our 2 year old - she was so tired she slept through just about everything. We also like the Beach Club area after hours - it was nice to be in EPCOT which was the only thing open into the evening hours, and you can just stroll out at your convenience and not have to wait for transportation in huge crowds to get to your room. On evenings she was particularly energetic we went to see the ducks by the water, met family on the Boardwalk and enjoyed shows, and were able to get a wide variety of snacks in the afternoons and evenings at the food counters that surround the water. Plus the pool at the Beach Club is one of the neatest things you'll ever see, and unlike the water parks if free!