Trial Run for Dogs in Resort Rooms

Do you think dogs should be allowed in guests' rooms?


  • Total voters
    1,260
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
It's interesting that they chose four resorts as a trial. I guess they wanted to test the concept at different price points?

It seems like limiting this to one resort would make more sense.
I thought that was interesting, too. Although the trial period may be to tweak policy, I suspect that it's really about the revenue. "How much money will this generate and should it be expanded?" - that's likely what it comes down to instead of guest satisfaction (regardless of which side you're on). Testing it at each tier suggests market survey. Oddly, I could see this policy most likely expanding at the Deluxe resorts as a result of the trial. Why? Higher dog fees ($75 per night instead of $50) at YC combined with the fact that families already in the Deluxes are most likely to have the disposable income to bring Fido along and pay the fee. Although I also suspect that more resorts across the tiers will be added. The trend with other pet friendly hotels points that way (and Disney may have done this in the belief that they were losing business to other pet friendly Orlando hotels).

But that ignores the other side of the question - how much money does Disney lose if the policy drives guests away? That's unknown - and one of the only reasons why this would fail - that the policy costs Disney more than it generates. (the other reason is if it just doesn't generate enough interest or revenue on its own - cf. Express Transportation). But the deck is already stacked due to the short notice - people aren't canceling or modifying reservations like they would if this had been delayed.

As before, I'm not crazy about this policy (I've had some pet friendly hotel rooms that were a mess - dog hair and suits on a business trip are a bad combo) - even though I don't think that a lot of the worst case scenarios here are at all likely. If you're strongly for or against, keep letting Disney know through the trial (and tying it to your dollars - that's the language that communicates best).
 
Doesn’t make it right. Lots of stuff on vacation aren’t necesseties. Actually, vacation itself isn’t. I don’t smoke & probably won’t ever bring dogs, but it isn’t against policy, so voice your concerns to WDW, don’t go, or get over it.
I already did. What’s the point of a discussion board if we’re not discussing & giving our opinion on things that are important to us. & I’ll ask you kindly not to tell me what I should or should not get over.
 
What I don’t understand is why everyone assumes that those of us who plan to bring our dogs are going to just leave them alone in the room for hours. I would never do that and most people who I know who have dogs wouldn’t do that either. I have my reservation for a Fort Wilderness cabin in May. I just made the arrangements for our dog to go to day camp at Best Friends each day. There will 3 adults plus the dog and we will be there for 4 nights. Each night one of us will stay in the cabin with the dog (also much more comfortable than sitting around a hotel room - which we have done) and the 4th night we will make arrangements for a dog sitter in the cabin so we can all go out together. I chose the cabins so I wouldn’t have to worry if she barks at night from hearing someone in the hallway. She will be up to date on her shots, etc. and will get groomed right before we leave. We walk our dog all over the college town that we live in which is packed with people most evenings and weekends and she never bothers anyone. You can tell if someone likes dogs or not and we never assume that someone wants to pet our dog. We pick up her poop and mind our own business. I have stayed in pet friendly hotels dozens of time with and without a dog and have never smelled “dogginess” in a hotel room.
 
My question for all the major asthma sufferers-how do you guarantee that you're not staying in a room that has had a dog in it now? Service dogs are allowed anywhere and in any room at any resort. Service dogs still bring in dander and hair and all the allergy related problems. Just curious.

Good question. Probably can't guarantee it. In my experience, the number of service animals on property is EXTREMELY small versus the number of guests on resort properties. The odds would very low. (just a guess) However, to your point, there was that risk before this new dog policy came up.

I have to believe that this is currently happening as it is.

I would suspect the cases of this are extremely low though, but I have no data to support that.

Dan
 
Exactly the problem. I'm sure they will start branching out from the designated rooms to accommodate these guests.
Are we even sure though that there are going to be "designated" rooms? So many have posted that they will be throughout the resort.
 
I thought that was interesting, too. Although the trial period may be to tweak policy, I suspect that it's really about the revenue. "How much money will this generate and should it be expanded?" - that's likely what it comes down to instead of guest satisfaction (regardless of which side you're on). Testing it at each tier suggests market survey. Oddly, I could see this policy most likely expanding at the Deluxe resorts as a result of the trial. Why? Higher dog fees ($75 per night instead of $50) at YC combined with the fact that families already in the Deluxes are most likely to have the disposable income to bring Fido along and pay the fee. Although I also suspect that more resorts across the tiers will be added. The trend with other pet friendly hotels points that way (and Disney may have done this in the belief that they were losing business to other pet friendly Orlando hotels)

Yeah the fact that they are charging $75 at YC definitely shows they are testing revenue. Especially since a YC room shouldn't be harder to clean than a suite at AoA or a cabin, it should be easier.
 
I just spoke to them Demetri at guest service has told me that being Muslim is a choice and you can pay to change resort. He also said you can avoid the lobby and sneak in round the back. Really nice

This is what bugs me. If you don't want to stay at a Dog (owner) friendly resort you may have to Pay a higher rate to stay else where. Allergies, etc are not a "choice". I still think that they should charge the $250 deep cleaning fee for dog owners just like they do for people that smoke in their room/balcony.... Regardless of how many days they stay.
 
For people worried about noise during naps, earplugs work great. I use the 3M TEKK ones that go up to 32 decibels when I travel. I'm super sensitive to noise and they block out so much.

Yes, I use them all the time. These little babies got me through a very crowded and noisy MK last trip. I'm super sensitive to noise and sometimes I become overwhelmed by it.
 
Thanks for posting this.

I'm surprised at the number of pet relief areas there are at AOfA and POR. It sounds like Disney is anticipating this will be a big draw for many people.
What a joke... there are 3 relief areas on the Fort Wilderness map. Now for a reality check. In August when I was there last, there were almost no poop-free areas at all. The poop was everywhere; on the grass, on the sidewalks, on the street, in "pet-free" loops, etc! There was no enforcing of the rules; it was awful. And the whole resort smelled horrible in that humid Florida air.
 
I just spoke to them Demetri at guest service has told me that being Muslim is a choice and you can pay to change resort. He also said you can avoid the lobby and sneak in round the back. Really nice

What? Are you for real or did autocorrect get you?
 
What a joke... there are 3 relief areas on the Fort Wilderness map. Now for a reality check. In August when I was there last, there were almost no poop-free areas at all. The poop was everywhere; on the grass, on the sidewalks, on the street, in "pet-free" loops, etc! There was no enforcing of the rules; it was awful. And the whole resort smelled horrible in that humid Florida air.

Eww. Gross. So are the relief areas on the map new to Fort Wilderness? Or are they the same one's that were there in August?

I'm trying to wrap my head around how this works. Obviously pet owners are responsible for scooping, but if they don't, will a designated cm do it once a day?
 
I don’t expect this to last long. After one incident (someone getting bit, or someone harming a dog, etc) this will be all over.
 
"We will also designate certain floors or sections of a hotel as dog-friendly, while the majority of areas will remain canine-free to accommodate Guests with allergies or other concerns."

https://disneyparks.disney.go.com/b...ect-walt-disney-world-hotels-starting-oct-15/

Are we even sure though that there are going to be "designated" rooms? So many have posted that they will be throughout the resort.

Resounding NO. Disney changes their rules, doesn't follow their rules, implements different than they project and at this point between here, twitter and facebook their own employees are giving out a WIDE range of answers to this. We've heard POR will have one building all the way to spread throughout the resort ........... and with 4 poop stations throughout, you can bet it won't be just one. If there is a market ......... they will open up more rooms. It's kinda like there are only 50 Free Dining rooms but as time goes on and there are empty rooms ........... hey, suddenly there are more free dining rooms available ..... the name of the game is FILL THE ROOMS, however you have to do it.

We see posts over and over, "I have a room reservation that fits x number of people. Can an additional person, friend, etc. fit in the room?" If the majority of per owners would be driving and all rooms have the potential to be pet friendly how easy would it be to sneak in a pet? Obviously the pet owner would have to hide the evidence from housekeeping or waive the service.

BUT people need MagicBands and FastPasses etc. Dogs need nothing .............. hands down they will be in the rooms and Disney won't even know it. Turn down housekeeping, your neighbors don't know if you are legal or not. Disney now says dogs okay, so how does your dog look different from the legal dog? Unless they start barking, likely no one will turn you in. AND you don't have to pay for it. It's no different that then folks who still smoke at their front door even though they signed off on the penalty, in terms of deterrence.

What I don’t understand is why everyone assumes that those of us who plan to bring our dogs are going to just leave them alone in the room for hours. I would never do that and most people who I know who have dogs wouldn’t do that either. I have my reservation for a Fort Wilderness cabin in May. I just made the arrangements for our dog to go to day camp at Best Friends each day. There will 3 adults plus the dog and we will be there for 4 nights. Each night one of us will stay in the cabin with the dog (also much more comfortable than sitting around a hotel room - which we have done) and the 4th night we will make arrangements for a dog sitter in the cabin so we can all go out together. I chose the cabins so I wouldn’t have to worry if she barks at night from hearing someone in the hallway. She will be up to date on her shots, etc. and will get groomed right before we leave. We walk our dog all over the college town that we live in which is packed with people most evenings and weekends and she never bothers anyone. You can tell if someone likes dogs or not and we never assume that someone wants to pet our dog. We pick up her poop and mind our own business. I have stayed in pet friendly hotels dozens of time with and without a dog and have never smelled “dogginess” in a hotel room.

MANY of us, would never leave our dogs that long but sadly, and I have no idea why ............ Disney World is different. On discussion boards, twitter, facebook and IRL (and I have over 130 on property stays plus all the off property) people think that Disney owes them, Disney is different, Disney picks up their trash, Disney will do whatever if you complain, manners are out the door, parenting ceases to exist at Disney ............ it's a vacation from reality and everything is someone else's problem.

If Disney had ....
- Announced this with 60 days notice
- Combined with an expanded doggie day care center
- PRACTICED at ONE resort, cabins make sense
- Had a few rules please .... like ..
- Breed Restrictions
- Size Restrictions
- No unattended dogs, take them to daycare
- Bookable category so no accidental cross overs
- Strict locations, set buildings, potty stations, all inclusive
- No dogs on ME - let those folks take private car
- No dogs in lobby, walkways other than their building etc
- No dogs on ANY bus ....... seriously that one was priceless.*
- AND how about having your employees all give the same stories,
it goes a long way in keeping down the concerns of many.

But no they have virtual no rules, to not follow industry standards .....
..... means other guests now have to be concerned about their vacations.

For Disney prices, I hope this pans out for them because there are lots of
really nice resorts in the area that provide better amenities.

With uber, lyft etc folks may find out how much more they can get for the price,
how close they can be to Disney and how they can be in bed before Disney Guests
even get on the bus.

*If that made no sense, apparently dogs can get on the inter-resort buses at POR and FW.
DOGS, that most folks usually walk with ......... but now they get to ride the buses.


DISCLAIMER:
I have two dogs, 70 lb and 12 lb. SPOILED ROTTEN!

If my child is killed by a pit bull, Doberman, rotweiller or poodle, I would say it is just the same as having my child killed by an alligator. My child was killed. How is it different?

This was covered at length after it happened. Nothing more needed.

This two incidents would be of different circumstances and responsibilities.

Two people can both be hit by cars but with two very different stories and circumstances, and responsibility.
 
Last edited:
What I don’t understand is why everyone assumes that those of us who plan to bring our dogs are going to just leave them alone in the room for hours. I would never do that and most people who I know who have dogs wouldn’t do that either. I have my reservation for a Fort Wilderness cabin in May. I just made the arrangements for our dog to go to day camp at Best Friends each day. There will 3 adults plus the dog and we will be there for 4 nights. Each night one of us will stay in the cabin with the dog (also much more comfortable than sitting around a hotel room - which we have done) and the 4th night we will make arrangements for a dog sitter in the cabin so we can all go out together. I chose the cabins so I wouldn’t have to worry if she barks at night from hearing someone in the hallway. She will be up to date on her shots, etc. and will get groomed right before we leave. We walk our dog all over the college town that we live in which is packed with people most evenings and weekends and she never bothers anyone. You can tell if someone likes dogs or not and we never assume that someone wants to pet our dog. We pick up her poop and mind our own business. I have stayed in pet friendly hotels dozens of time with and without a dog and have never smelled “dogginess” in a hotel room.

Because generally speaking, most people book Disney resorts to go to the parks all day. Plus, many people leave their dogs inside all day while they work anyways and since Disney is allowing people to leave their dogs all day, I'm sure lots of people will do exactly that.
 
Nope "religion is a choice" direct quote.

Wow, I'm not particularly religious, but I do think that is actually kind of disrespectful to say to a guest!

Disney prides itself on being accommodating to guests from all over the world, and for a CM to say that to a guest just seems wrong. And telling a guest to "sneak around the back"? What the heck?!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

GET A DISNEY VACATION QUOTE

Dreams Unlimited Travel is committed to providing you with the very best vacation planning experience possible. Our Vacation Planners are experts and will share their honest advice to help you have a magical vacation.

Let us help you with your next Disney Vacation!











facebook twitter
Top