Sorry! More info: This is for 2 adults, 3 kids (15, 11, 9). First timers!I think we could use more info - 2 adults? Any previous experience with character dining, eating at CRT, or strong desire to do so?
Based on absolutely nothing else, I think Narcoossee's and Jiko are strong contenders, along with Toppolino's. I've personally always wanted to do LC but based on a desire from a long time ago and it sounds like it's not necessarily as good as it once was. Flying Fish and Disney Springs places don't really jump out at me. I'm pretty sure we went to Yachtsman's and it was okay but I don't remember dying to go back. But I've done Akershus and CRT and wouldn't use 2 credits at Brown Derby. Haven't been to Tiffins - so that's a wild card for me.
I'd definitely agree with these, given the update with kids. And I totally get wanting a good value - but I say lead with your heart. If it sounds like a good experience for you and your kids (and you know your own style best), it'll be "worth it" no matter what you choose.- We ate at CRT when the kids were much younger and the food was unmemorable but fine, however, eating in the castle has its appeal.
- Narcoossee - My memories of it is that it lacked the beautiful presentation of Tiffin's, Jiko and Cali Grill and the menu wasn't particularly interesting (more on the plain side). But, it closed for an extended period for renovations and we have not been back sine it re-opened and we would try it again.
- Topolino's - gets great reviews (especially the burrata appetizer!) and the setting seems special. We have not been there, but maybe this next trip!