Enchantment, Brillance, or Majesty

[shopn24seven]

Definitely cruising Mar 2016 and these are my options. DCL is just out of my priceline.
Never cruised RCL, so I need reviews.
Either Bahamas or West Caribbean.
Any pix would be a PLUS.

 

[holula]

I've been on Enchantment - I sailed on her last week. If I sailed her again (which is unlikely) I would get a room far away from the casino, and probably aft. I stayed on deck four forward and my closest elevators were right under the casino. I'm not allergic to smoke but I am very sensitive and that whole area I found intolerable. I couldn't deal with deck five at all because of the smoke and could only use the entrance to the theatre on deck six.

She was a nice ship though. Well maintained. Rooms and bathrooms are small. Food was excellent. MDR service was probably one of the best I've had in. 13 cruises, both DCL and non DCL. Royal made sure there was lots to do throughout the day also. The pools were never as crowded as Disney. They make the most amazing sandwiches in Park Cafe in the solarium.

 

[Mpadovani2]

Definitely cruising Mar 2016 and these are my options. DCL is just out of my priceline. Never cruised RCL, so I need reviews. Either Bahamas or West Caribbean. Any pix would be a PLUS.

have sailed all 3. Brilliance is a great choice. Recently revitalized with new restaurants, nursery, and shows. Best of fun and elegance. Enchantment was stretched to make room for more cabins, but not much addition to common space - can be tight. Majesty is very small and with shorter itineraries can be a party ship. I am sailing on Brilliance again this April....can't wait!

 

[dunnhorn]

Looks like you are doing the same exact analysis I recently did!

Another one to consider if you don't have kids is the Celebrity Constellation. We decided against it because it didn't look kid friendly. I don't even know if it had a movie theater.

At any rate - in my research I found that RCCL is about to sell the Majesty in 2016. That is never a good sign - they are putting her out to sea, as it were. So I would take that one off your list.

We ended up choosing the Brilliance.... I found some YouTube videos online - it does look cool.