Big vote for Capt Marvin, and not just any Capt Marvin but specifically the FULL day tour.
We did it on out 11/9 Western, Me DW, DS 14, DD's 10 and 9.
People will warn you you might not get there in time, and say
DCL only lets their excursions off the ship first. Well I can tell you first hand, we were on the FIRST tender and it was no where near full.
It was like a private trip. My family of 5, and 5 other passengers, one Mom and Dad with a 8 YR old and a couple from believe it or not Boston. We were the only ones from the ship, the other families were vacationing on the island.
We did three seperate snorkle stops, as well as Sting Ray City. Stopped at a private Yacht club for a home made local lunch of baked Mahi Mahi, shredded pork, coconut bread salad etc. ( that is five stops incase you are counting) Our first stop for Conch was cleaned, marinaded while we snorkled, and served as an appetizer on the beach.
It was THE best day of the whole trip,
Castaway Cay included.
We had a professional photographer make a movie of the whole day which Marvin's provides, no obligation to buy. We did for $50.00 and now is a permanent reminder of a temporary feeling.
They provide everything, except towels and sun screen, collect them the day ahead from the pool so you are ready to rock in the morning. We had room service sent at 7 AM, the earliest option. When I marked the card I checked to the left of the 7AM box indicating earlier is better. It arrived at 6:50- Perfect. We took most of the food off with us. We were at the dive shop, a short walk from the tender drop off before 8AM. We were in the theater tender meeting spot by 7:15.
It really made a difference in the quality of the experience being with such a small group.
They had us back at the tender by 3:30, that gave us plenty of time to go to the Hard Rock and buy T shirts while hords of DCL passengers waited in line for the tenders. We went to the line at 4:15, collected our complimentary glass of fruit punch and got on board with no wait. I believe there were 2 more tenders that came afer ours so we were not the last stragelers by any means.
PS.... Bring along those Fuji under water cameras (one for each in your party as a minimum) from Wallmart. Pics came out great. Also pack three or four cans of cheese wiz snack food. It brings in the fish like crazy. This is also true for Castway Cay which we really did enjoy ( Second Best Day). The fish there followed us the entire time we were in the water.
My kids think I am Aqua Man !
What ever you decide, I wish you the time of your life as we had.
Bob