Near resort: (many offer 10% discount with room key)
1) Scott's...Seafood/bar in the marina and right across the water from resort (have a happy hour)
2) Social Bakery...also in marina good desserts
3) Bucci and Murray's...also in marina and kind of a mix of foods (Italian, Irish, seafood, pizza...have a happy hour)
4) San Miguel's...Mexican (haven't had food there yet but want to...have a happy hour)
5) Poseidon...seafood with outdoor bar and upper deck bar as well as huge indoor area. They are in the shopping center next to resort (by Kroger)
6) Jane's Bistro...quaint seafood place (haven't eaten there yet but hear it is really good)...also in Kroger center
7) Guiseppe's...Italian, pizza, sports bar-ish...really good and great prices...also in Kroger center
8) World of Beer...neat beer place with good food...also in Kroger Center
Not right near resort:
1) Frosty Frog...frozen drink place (like Fat Tuesdays)...kinda divey but really good food and great drinks (and in Coligny plaza with shopping about 8-10 min drive from resort)
2) Marley's Island Grill...great early bird deals and drink happy hours. Seafood and really good (near Coligny)
3) Stack's...about 1 mile down the parkway...breakfast place (diner type place they also have lunch but I've only done breakfast)
4) Alfred's...fancy tiny quaint little secret place across the parkway from resort...authentic German food and sooooo good (make resie)
5) Frankie Bones...steak is good here and great early bird deals...is up the parkway north of resort about 8-10 min drive
6) Crazy Crab...seafood and another one with great outdoor patio with water view...also up north of resort and kinda right when coming on island
7) Skull Creek Boathouse...more seafood and huge place with outdoor on water seating and several bars (kind of #1 place folks go so it gets SUPER busy, best to go for lunch like at 11:30-12:00 or weeknights and early...they don't take resies)...up by Frankie Bones and Crazy Crab but off the parkway a bit, about 12 mins from resort
I've been to a bunch of others, some so-so (like Crane's Tavern Steakhouse, Salty Dog, Black Marlin and Nick's) and some not as great as people say (like One Hot Mama's, which is BBQ and Chow Daddy's....I'd even put Skull Creek in here too but it's worth trying for the location) and some downright yucky (like Il Carpaccio Italian)