Didn't Donny Osmond do Joseph when it was revived?
Michael Damien played Joseph when the revival opened. Not sure if Donny ever did the part on Broadway.
Here's my list:
Favorites:
Rent
Les Miz
The Who's Tommy
Billy Elliot (in London, I haven't seen it on B'way yet)
Ragtime
Man of La Mancha
Wicked
The Secret Garden
The worst:
All Shook Up
Footloose
Titanic
Favorite performances: Hugh Jackman in The Boy From Oz, the original cast of Rent, Harvey Firestein in Hairspray, Brian Stokes Mitchell or Nathan Lane in anything.
Funniest: Spamalot/The Producers
Saddest: Blood Brothers
Most original: Movin' Out, 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
Most fun jukebox musical: Jersey Boys
Funniest songs:
"The Song that Goes Like This", "Diva's Lament" - Monty Python's Spamalot
"Where Did We Go Right?" - The Producers
Saddest songs:
"The Letter" - Billy Elliot
"A Little Fall of Rain" - Les Miz
"Tell Me It's Not True" - Blood Brothers
"Back to Before" - Ragtime
"Left Behind" - Spring Awakening
Best Love Song:
"You're Timeless to Me" - Hairspray
Best Dance Sequences: "Angry Dance" and "Swan Lake" arial ballet from Billy Elliot
Most jaw-dropping opening sequence: The Lion King
Songs I never get sick of:
"La Vie Boheme" - Rent
"Defying Gravity" - Wicked
"You Can't Stop The Beat" - Hairspray
"The Impossible Dream" - Man of La Mancha
"Electricity" - Billy Elliot
"One Day More" - Les Miz
"Tenterfield Saddler" - The Boy From Oz
"Make Them Hear You" - Ragtime
"Totally *$##@!" - Spring Awakening
"Lily's Eyes" - The Secret Garden
Funniest Ad-Lib
Ever: "There's a cute guy in that," - Hugh Jackman after an audience member mentioned the X-Men movies.
I'm sure there's lots more - as you can tell, I love musicals!!!