I don’t necessarily see it as a contradiction. One public area with furniture they may be in is the lobby. Not everyone can bypass the front desk, and if they decide they need to review your vaccination paperwork, pet guests may actually be required to go to the front desk. So they have to have this kind of wording so people are aware of the rules (whether enforced is another matter).
The contradiction comes from whether dogs are or are not allowed in common areas that all other guests are using. The impression I got from their statements, initial responses etc is that non-dog folks should not be impacted because these dogs would be restricted to specific rooms and areas of resort with their "pet walkway" to their "relief area." Folks were stating there should be no crossover of non-dog guests with the dogs - so nothing to fear.
But the followup comments and statements seem to indicate that the dogs are permitted on all the walkways all around resort, all the common areas including lobby that are not "walled off" like food court, pool, fitness center. This leaves open dogs at bus stops (they can ride internal bus), dogs at playgrounds, dogs on beaches, dogs on common walkways etc. You can't profess to non-dog guests their vacation won't be impacted because the dogs will be in restricted areas, when in fact they won't.
It gets frustrating when a place you love to go and should be able to do better, throws out this totally new random program with little consistency in information (other than the price), such uninformed CMs (you hand them all a packet of FACTS before you do PR release), so little time to prepare and essentially removing 3 moderately priced resorts from those in that budget .......... with a fairly rule-less policy not in keeping with industry standards.
Disclaimer: Have two dogs who are spoiled and they vacation with us, to dog friendly beach. Would never consider taking them to Disney and locking them all in a room all week. I would spend double the money and let them go to the pet resort and be pampered.
I am not allergic nor fearful of dogs, but I fully appreciate and feel terrible for those who are. I have dealt with neighbors in two communities (nice ones) who don't understand rules and boundaries for dog bathroom time. At Disney I expect it to be worse since these folks will be gone in a few days and have no personal incentive to scoop, or get to proper spots. It's Disney where sadly guests consistently do what they please as if others don't matter.
How much is a day of doggy care? You're already paying $50 per night to have a dog stay in your room. Is that $50 per dog? Or per dog room?
It cost us $35 per night for 24 hour care at the place where we boarded my last dog. We sprang for grooming on top of that. My current dog only stayed there once because Grandma and Grandpa will take her. She's so sweet and adorable they enjoy doting on her. Our previous dog wasn't as lovable. LOL!
Anyhow, like everything Disney, this dog friendly deal is gonna cost the guests big time.
I think $27 per day per dog.
If I brought my two to Disney and left in room, $350 a week.
If I brought my two to Disney & added Daycare, $750 a week.
If I take my two to their Pet Resort here at home, $800+ a week. But that includes me not taking them back and forth with us (8 hrs each way), back and forth to doggie day care, two baths one before I pick them up, private or group activities like swimming lessons, ice cream .....which do you think my furbabies will enjoy?