There are alot of choices to be had, and IMHO, Yacht Club Galley would be toward the bottom of the list. The food is fine, it isn't that. There just isn't anything interesting about it.
My first choice would be Spoodle's. You will be right there on the Boardwalk when it is time to meet your friends.
If you don't mind walking to the Boardwalk after eating, I would go to either Palio or the Yachtsman Steakhouse.