Giving up the bubble would be very hard for me. Right now we are crunching the numbers, because we want to go to the beach for spring break. If I have to downgrade to do both I will. We desperately need vacations!
I don't think you'll be disappointed at all staying off property. For me, I feel like I enter the bubble just being in the Kissimmee area with all there is to see and do. Sometimes I feel like you miss out on so much being on property. Not to mention the rooms are so much bigger and nicer for a fraction of the cost depending on where you stay. We typically get the Rosen Center for around $99 a night and you feel like a high roller staying there in those plush beds and quiet rooms. lol
^^ I second what Alice said. I mean, to compare our off site and on site trips (obviously, based on my opinion) to give you an idea:
Pros of Onsite:
- Yes, it really is a cool feeling being at the Disney resort, especially since we stayed at Movies with kids. They absolutely loved the theming, and it really did give an immersive feeling. They loved the resort pool and having other kids around. It really does give a fun "vibe". And on one hand, it's nice to not have to drive.
Cons of Onsite:
- Less space is the obvious (and huge) one. Lack of kitchen - I found staying on site so inconvenient for meals. Get up, get dressed, walk to the cafeteria, walk back, brush teeth, finish getting ready, walk back to catch the bus etc... Kids didn't enjoy that, and it got old really fast. And the constant noise was another drawback - I felt like I never got a break: loud parks to loud busses to loud restaurants/cafeterias to loud pool to even just the noise of the room etc... people walking by your room, noise of the ventilation systems etc... Disliked all the standing around waiting for a bus, as did the kids (obviously would be different if you had your own vehicle at the resort, which we didn't). Didn't find relying on the bus any faster than having our own car and driving from off site (but again, we stayed at All Stars, I know other resorts have faster service). 60 day FP+.
Pros of Off Site:
- The space and privacy. The quietness and chance to recharge your batteries. The kitchen. The laundry. The private pool. Having your own transportation, not having to wait for a bus to show up, come and go as and when you please. Much easier to go off site if you want.
Cons of Off Site:
- 30 day FP+ was seriously the only con IMO.
To me, staying off-site felt like more of a real vacation. It was more relaxing and enjoyable. Not so overwhelming. I'll never forget coming back from Hollywood Studios, and DH and I swimming under the stars in our own private pool at 1:00 am. It was so nice. I loved being able to wake up, walk out on the lanai and eat a leisurely breakfast by the pool.
Both were enjoyable, but off site more so. And I agree with Alicefan - to me, just being in the area feels exciting.