I can only tell you about Coronado... which I absolutely love. I got a free upgrade to a preferred room when I stayed there in February (and have stayed several times before, both before and after the room refurbs). It’s one of my favorite resorts because I’m spoiled for choice on food options, the grounds are lovely, the price is usually right, and the renovated rooms feel more in the realm of deluxe than some of the pre-renovated deluxe rooms felt (sorry, looking at you AKL and WL pre-refurb).
The outside door/motel style room is not a favorite of mine, so that’s probably the biggest “con” in my opinion as having noisy groups pass your room can be disruptive. I didn’t notice that at CSR but have had problems with it at Port Orleans before. I also would probably book CSR all the time except for one thing... I’m a balcony lover. It’s a lovely thing to make coffee or pour a glass of wine and head out onto the balcony. BUT so long as you’re decent, the Coronado grounds have lots of benches and great outdoor sitting areas to have a giant “balcony”.
The fact that Disney put NBA media up at the non-tower rooms should show just how truly upgraded they are from typical rooms. I love the keurig and the hard flooring. Not to mention... you now have three bridges bar (homemade churros, lake views), the lobby bar in the tower (sorry can’t remember the name right now - Barcelona?) with FANTASTIC servers and wonderful gin drinks, Dahlia and Toledo at the top of Gran Destino, Rix Sports Bar (very underrated for casual TS in my opinion) in the former “main building”, a great QS option in Mercado Coronado with some unique choices there, the pool bar at the Dig Site with fantastic frozen drinks and basic but delicious nachos, there’s another outdoor bar near the old “main building” on the water, another table service I’ve never tried (maya grill), the grab n go pastry shop Rix Cafe... need I go on? And the Gran Destino lobby is just gorgeous. Great ambiance!
Okay after that love letter, I’m irritated that the NBA is there because I love this resort so much now. One of my happiest memories is just sitting in bed eating a treat from amorette’s watching old school Mickey/Donald/Goofy cartoons. And you can start Stacey on demand whenever you like! It’s also one of the most centrally located Disney resorts - it’s sort of at the intersection of everything. Bus service has always been good for me, especially if you request to stay near buildings 2-4. I could have a really amazing trip by taking what i’d spend on the club level “upgrade” and putting those funds on a gift card to enjoy around the resort.
Maybe I’ll book too...