Just back from a 2 night stay. I don't suppose that with a 67 page thread it really matters much what one person thinks or cares, but I found the place very meh.
Theme is fine, but not really all that strong. Hotel employees were pleasant but it's not exactly high service. There were a few issues with our stay -- not exactly anyone's fault but nobody bending over backwards to seem all that worried about it. Computers were down when we checked in. They had to monkey with the system just to get us keys to use as express passes and we had to return. In the meantime, they had to take a ton of information and the line got crazy. I don't remember how long we were made to wait but it took a while and seemed longer since we were anxious to get to the parks. On check out, the valet couldn't find our keys and so we had to wait for them to straighten it out. We had a late flight out so had asked for 30 extra minutes to check out of our room. They said no. Late check out, of course, is never guaranteed and we were hoping but not expecting, but it added insult to injury to have asked for a late check out, be told no, gotten out on time, only to be made to stand in the humid air in the valet for at least that long while they ran around trying to figure out what they had done with our keys.
I also had a bit of a weird experience at the attractions desk. I had a 2005 ticket that had an entitlement on it, and I needed a bar coded ticket to use at the turnstiles. I got a can't do type who wanted to keep telling me what couldn't be done, while I gently had to prod to keep trying. Eventually it got done, but that was sort of par for the course.
Room was fine. Decent amenities, bed was ok. The bottom line is that what you're paying over $300 a night for is being able to walk to the parks and express pass, and they know it. There is really no reason for them to try particularly hard. Maybe they usually do. I dunno, I'm a sample size of one. But the truth is that if it were motel 6 quality, but had the same location and express pass, they'd probably sell it. And I'll probably pay it again if I go back.