mummabear
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- May 2, 2012
I'm curious about this... How do the two programs compare? Our experiences with Girl Scouts in the US were pretty mixed. It was fun when the girls were very young, but as they got older it got more "girly" and my daughter was really jealous of her friends in Boy Scouts who were doing wilderness camping and shooting sports while her GS troop was doing cabin camping and art classes. So I can totally get why girls might agitate to be a part of the boys' program if that program is more suited to what they expected/wanted out of scouting. My DD left GS in favor of 4H because of that, but that only worked because we live in a rural area with an active 4H program; in the city, scouting is often the only organization providing outdoors activities (other than team sports) for kids so the difference between GS and BSA has more impact.
I am a Pippin leader this is the youngest group of Girl guides for girls aged 5-7, a minimum of 60% of our activities are to be done outdoors.
We take the girls to do things like kayaking, archery, campfires including learning to cook over campfires, rock climbing, hiking, learning to build a trail, Burma trails, beach visits etc.
We also do art, cooking, and various other badges although all badges will have an outdoor component. We also do things like Visit fire stations, or go to the pool.
I do think though that it is very leader dependent how much adventure/outdoors your programme is, and a little based on location, we are 10 minutes from hiking trails or the beach so it's really easy for our unit to do.
My daughters make friends are in Cubs from what they and their parents say they play games and do crafts like making kites. I think they are similar programs and just they have a newer leader.
I don't think boys would be joining in huge numbers if it was opened up, the pink uniform may be enough to put them off-it even puts off some girls.
But DDS best friend (a boy) wanted to join, he is very feminene and the boys make fun of him, he wants to wear pink and do baking etc, GG would not allow him. I advised his mom that I was happy to take he fight as far as she was as the u it was happy to have him. If she wanted to cause a fuss and go to the paper etc she would have us stand with her but she ultimately decided she didn't want to put him in that position.